Boards Index › General discussion › Getting serious › BIG BROTHER watching from birth……….
-
AuthorPosts
-
22 May, 2006 at 12:24 am #4091
Edinburgh Evening News:
‘Big Brother’ plan to store every baby on computer
EVERY newborn child in Edinburgh and the Lothians faces being stored on a “Big Brother-style” national database under a major shake-up of Scotland’s child protection system.The computerised files would be kept “live” until the child reaches the age of 16 and will include personal details of their health, family life and education
The child’s file will be closed when they reach 16, but it will then be kept on record for up to 75 years.
Teachers, police, GPs and social workers will be able to access the files to check for signs of abuse.
If the child is regularly late for school or their behaviour changes dramatically, the details could be put into the system where it is hoped it will build up a picture of the child’s overall welfare.
But the move was described today by SNP justice spokesman Kenny MacAskill as another step towards Big Brother-style surveillance.
He said: “I find it rather ominous and I would want to know just what the possible benefits were. The safety of children is paramount, but this raises as many problems as it does solutions.
“Who will be able to access this information? It sounds very Big Brother-ish and raises many implications for people’s privacy.
“A lot of assurances would be required as to what the proposed benefits were. It’s all very Orwellian.”
The national database is being planned by ministers to revolutionise information sharing between different agencies and improve protection for vulnerable children.
The move follows a series of high-profile cases of child protection failures in Edinburgh and the Lothians.
In March, two-year-old East Lothian boy Derek Doran died after drinking his parents’ methadone. He had been found dead in his bed by his mother last December at their home at Elphinstone, near Tranent.
And last year, three-year-old Michael McGarrity was found alone in a Leith flat with the body of his drug-addict mother, having survived for six weeks on scraps of food.
In 2002, 11-week-old Caleb Ness died at the hands of his brain-damaged father after being released into the care of his drug-addict mother.
It is hoped the scheme will also see fewer young people referred to the Scottish Children’s Reporter Association either for protection purposes or because of committing offences.
Last year more than 50,000 children were referred to the SCRA – a record figure.
The scheme is to be piloted in Highland Council from September 3 before being extended across the country, according to the Scottish Executive.
Every newborn child in the Highland region and around 500 Inverness schoolchildren will be logged into the system during the trial.
Families have been told they will be consulted about the nature of information that is held.
A spokesman for the Scottish Executive said: “Highland’s experience will also be used to help other local authorities prepare for the roll-out of the new systems.”
But a human rights expert warned the new system may be open to abuse.
John Scott, former head of the Scottish Human Rights Centre, said: “The positive aspects of this are fairly obvious but bringing so much information into one place brings with it the scope for abuse.
“The important thing it to ensure there are very clear safeguards in place.”
22 May, 2006 at 12:39 am #220415Looks like we are moving another step closer to having a national database of people….the next thing they will be taking DNA samples at birth. :?
Although, in theory, a record of all children is a good idea……I am all in favour of protecting children…..but surely it isn’t a good thing to allow so many people access to these records?
Fine…the Police and Doctors….but teachers???? :?
Do they mean just the headmasters….or can any teacher have a check into a child’s background? Why should they have access to a child’s family/medical history – anything they need to know they should already have info on.
I think a system like this could be abused…mistakes happen…people can be accused of things that aren’t true (how many innocent parents have had their child put on an at risk register?)
I just hope that they regulate it properly, don’t allow too many people free access to it, and genuinely use it to help troubled children.
22 May, 2006 at 1:00 am #220416Tommy still a good idea, when it has been reported that there is Teachers workin within the system who are on the sex register…??
22 May, 2006 at 1:02 am #220417@abitofmary_j wrote:
Tommy still a good idea, when it has been reported that there is Teachers workin within the system who are on the sex register…??
That was another concern that came to mind…. :?
22 May, 2006 at 1:21 am #220418@tommy-toxen wrote:
I’m sure access to the database would be regulated, monitored and logged.
if anything, it’ll help catch out the sex offenders if they try to abuse it.
come on Tommy, do you think all Beasts r regulated…??? and not all database is safe… and what if someone who can access this database is an undectected Beast…?? this would be his dream of wet dreams all this info on innocent children…. and all at a click of a button eh….!
22 May, 2006 at 2:45 am #220419I think anything that regulates and protects our future generation of children can’t be a bad thing, the system needs to be very carefully monitored though, but abuse can cover a wider scope of things, its very well known that some children who are abused never show the outward signs, so even then theres a likely hood that some will slip through the net, however tightly it is binded.
22 May, 2006 at 5:26 am #220420In theory this appears to be a good idea, anything that will help a child to grow up safely and ‘normall’ whatever that is then thats ok with me.
however, herein lies the problem, yes lets give all the agencies fingertip information where we can……but who is going to ensure those agencies ACTUALLY TALK TO EACH OTHER?????
hugssss xxxxx
22 May, 2006 at 7:39 am #220421It’s an excellent idea .
I agree with the DNA at birth too .
That way any future criminals will have their DNA identity on computer
It’s just like ID cards – if you keep on the right side of the law , you have nothing to fear
22 May, 2006 at 10:14 pm #220422Surely we’re all on x number of databases anyway, not to mention a master copy every birth, marriage or death certificate being held centrally.
-
AuthorPosts
Get involved in this discussion! Log in or register now to have your say!